Our family recently spent a Saturday at the Sam Noble Museum of Natural History in Norman, Oklahoma. We awed at the huge head of the Pentaceratops which according to the sign holds the Guinness World Record for the world’s biggest dinosaur skull. We saw the skeleton of the largest known adult Apatosaurus (93 feet long!) that filled a large two-story exhibit on “ancient life.”
But most of all, what I experienced was dissonance, hearing two contradictory messages at the same time, one from the exhibit and one from my spirit.
The extensive exhibit on evolution pointed out the four pillars of the theory: 1-each kind of life has variety. So there are all kinds of dogs. 2-traits are inherited. So I look like a combination of my parents. 3-evolution requires time. The exhibit claimed the earth is 4.6 billion years old. 4-only the strongest survive. The exhibit focused on a group of birds which could only find hard nuts to eat during hard times. Only the ones with the appropriate beaks survived.
We left the museum with all sorts of thoughts. A visitor’s response area included a posting of recent comments. Many urged the museum to present a creationist point of view. One note warned that anybody who believed what the museum taught was headed to hell.
Ironically, the next day I was reading Ecclesiastes 3. I was struck by how this Old Testament book framed my thoughts about the visit.
First, Ecclesiastes 3:18-22 compares humans to animals. The writer of Ecclesiastes looks at life “under the sun” which is his way of saying that in the book he views life from a secular point of view. From that viewpoint, both animals and humans are dust and return to dust. Although I don’t think the museum had any human bones, much of the exhibit was a trip through an animal cemetery. All the animals there are dead. The museum looked almost entirely at the past. That, of course is its intent. It views life under the sun.
Second, Ecclesiastes 3:1-8 stresses that there is a time for everything: “a time to be born and a time to die.” It helped me to understand that there was a time of dinosaurs and a time without dinosaurs. Ecclesiastes aims to say that despite our efforts life just goes on. Despite all we do, beyond all our abilities, regardless of our study and our technology, there is a time to be born and a time to die. Every skeleton in that museum followed that pattern. There were no exceptions.
Third, Ecclesiastes 3:9-11 stands in contrast to 3:1-8. In the first section the writer uses the word “time” 29 times. We are stuck in time. It does not matter whether the time is 4.6 billion years or 4000 years. We are stuck in it. There is nothing we can do to transcend time. In Ecclesiastes 3:9-11 the writer adds another dimension. Ecclesiastes says we have eternity in our minds (Ecc 3:11). Despite living in the Cenozoic Era, we all have an urge that there is something more. It frustrates us that we are confined to this era when we have a sense that there is something beyond time itself. That is where I felt the dissonance.
That verse in Ecclesiastes helped me to express what I was feeling when I left the museum. Is the museum’s presentation of existence all there is? We live, we evolve and then we die? If we are a big animal, they put our bones on display? I left thinking there had to be something else to life.
Fourth, Ecclesiastes 3 treated the realities of this time and this world much like the Noble Museum. But Ecclesiastes is unable to resist mentioning the one word that the museum refuses to mention. Despite our eventual return to dust, regardless of our being limited to time, even with our sense that there is something else out there, Ecclesiastes says the word: God. God has made everything beautiful (Ecc 3:11). It all fits together. Life is filled with variety. We inherit traits of our parents. There is a time for everything. Yes, even the strong survive. Based on Ecclesiastes’ reflection on life, it is not by chance, but by design.
I was struck by how Ecclesiastes 3 gave voice to what I sensed in viewing the delightfully prepared exhibits at the museum. The scientists join Ecclesiastes in viewing “life under the sun.” I think the writer of Ecclesiastes would have enjoyed the afternoon touring the exhibits. He might have added “there is a time to go to museums and a time to stay home.” But Ecclesiastes senses that there is something more. Whether one spends a day at a museum or looks around at the world, one is filled with dissonance. Ecclesiastes allows that dissonance to lead him to God.
I’ve decided to follow that same course.